I arrived in Williamsport mere months after the opening of the Bullfrog and have always liked its food, beers and look. I have been a regular, I have been away for a while, the Bullfrog stayed its course.
When you visit the Bullfrog Brewery you can expect a number of things, a selection of damn fine beers, a menu featuring different and delicious food, some great live music and nonchalant service.
I fell in love with the Grilled Portobello sandwich long ago. When needing a heftier lunch the Chicken Cheesesteak was my preference. Smother either in the Bullfrog’s hot sauce with some sweet potato fries and ya got it gong on.
If burgers are your choice go with the Pittsburger (order it cooked Pittsburgh Style) bacon provolone, grilled onions and mushrooms……my mouth’s watering how ‘bout you?
Evening entrees are varied and equally fine. My three choices; Pittsburgh Steak Stack, Pork Schnitzel, Garlic Crusted Chicken. Not necessarily in that order.
To enhance your meal the Bullfrog has a choice of fine beers, it is a brewery after all. The On Tap Now area of their web site is not always up to date but can give an idea of what you can expect. While their Billtown Blonde, a Bullfrog staple (This lightly colored ale has a delicate floral aroma and flavor reminiscent of Williamsports first breweries, clean and crisp with just a touch of lingering sweetness leading to a dry, balanced finish. 6% abv), my preference for darker heavier beers leads me to the Smoked Porter (A big, RICH dark ale with a complex combination of beechwood smoked malts, chocolate, coffee and caramel flavors rounding out the beers smooth creamy body. 6% abv) and Susquehanna Oatmeal Stout (A big, burly Oatmeal Stout full of chocolate, caramelized malt and coffee flavors. This stout has a rich mouthfeel and a smooth, roasty finish. 6.2% ABV). I have heard the Coffee Cream Stout (A coffee and beer lovers delight! 10 pounds of freshly roasted Sumatran Mandling coffee and 55 pounds of lactose (milk sugar) give this beer its oh so smooth and creamy coffee flavor. 5.8% abv) is exceptional. If it’s on tap grab a sample.
Downtown Williamsport on West Fourth Street The Bullfrog is across form the Community Arts Center and a stones throw from the new movie theater. Easy parking, light, bright streets make it an inviting dining location.
The Bullfrog features a variety of live music, some free, some with a small cover. If you plan to be dining while a band is playing gravitate toward the back of the restaurant. I guess I’m too old because for me the bands are too loud.
Alas, nothing is perfect. The Bullfrog’s weakness has always been its service. For a dozen years, through dozens of people, slow service and cool personalities have permeated the Bullfrog. Is that a reason to not visit? Not at all, just allow for more time and have friends along for conversation.
Food 4
Delicious food, diverse selection
Beer 4.5
Some out of this world beers
Atmosphere 4
Wood & copper casual and warm.
Location 4
Right downtown Williamsport with plenty of nearby parking
Service 2
Slow and lacking personality
Misc 3
Great live music although bands are loud for space
Overall 4
The Bullfrog Brewery is a must for Williamsport dining.
The Billtown Crawlers rating system is based on a 5 point system with Food, Atmosphere, Location, Service and Overall as ever-present categories. Misc. and restaurant specific offerings may be included as appropriate. The Overall rating is not an average of all ratings.
(originally posted June 2008)